The things that make me laugh, weep, and live.
What it is and what it's not
Published on July 24, 2004 By Shulamite In Philosophy
Do we really go to God for forgiveness? Or do we all too often bring him reasons why He should excuse us?

An excuse is not the same thing as forgiveness; if there is an excuse, we don't need forgivenes.

We say, "I know I did wrong, God, but you know I was late for work..." or "The kids were really grouchy..." or "that guy hates me though..." or "I didn't know this would happen...." These are excuses for behavior. I think we often have some good excuses. But more often, there is real sin we must have forgiven. Some amount in it that the excuse doesn't absolve.

We can only say, "I did wrong. forgive me." God looks right at us, dead-on at the sin. And he forgives us. If we present excuses, aren't we really denying a need for forgiveness? I think so. "but it wasn't my fault," means I've not done wrong. How arrogant! How haughty. God hates haughtiness. He says so in the proverbs and psalms, and well, all over the Bible. But that's what we do.

The trouble is, we don't want to forgive those who hurt us. We want to hear their excuses. We rationalize with them and then call it forgiveness. But that's not forgiveness. Forgiveness is us looking dead-on at the sin and forgiving the person for the sin, for the hurt they caused us. It's not forgetting, in my opinion. But it is saying, "I'm okay. We're okay." You may have to say this 7 times 77 times just to fully forgive the one offense; if you do it that many times, chances are the forgiveness is actualized. And we can't be forgiven if we don't forgive others. The Bible is very clear on this. Jesus Himself said it. I don't think he was joking. He isn't crazy, and he isn't a liar. That leaves this: He's who He says He is and He means what He says.

All this comes from CS Lewis' essay called "On Forgiveness." I highly recommend it for further information on the topic. It can be found in The Weight of Glory. I'm interested in any additions to this, any comments. Is this true for you, Christian?

Comments
on Jul 24, 2004
If we present excuses, aren't we really denying a need for forgiveness? I think so


I think so too. We don't need excuses, because God's love is unconditional. Love is for-giving, and God has lots of spiritual wealth to give. Most of our guilt and feelings of inner turmoil are self-inflicted, caused by resistence to God's love and forgiveness. When we learn that we are here for a purpose, and that we are constantly bathed in the love of God, we can establish authentic inner peace. We find the Source of spiritual wealth, and can begin to love ourself more, which in turn enables us love others as ourself. Forgiveness is a letting go of our grudges, hurts and conflicts, which we harbour within. Forgiveness leads to inner-freedom. It's a worthwhile spiritual practice.
on Jul 24, 2004
opinions are ass holes and everybody has one, how dare you you desecrate CS Lewis' words in such a manner, you have no right to talk about forgiveness unless you have been there..I can tell from your tone you are just regurgitating someone else's thoughts. So please stick to what you know..you are one of those people who cheapens christianity
on Jul 25, 2004
opinions are ass holes and everybody has one


We're all a bunch of ass holes. When we can say, "I am that" to any insult that we throw at another person, we are on the road to wisdom and growth, in my opinion. And we will also be on the way to learning how to forgive. How do you know we haven't been there, by the way?
on Jul 26, 2004
I really liked this article. I ahve done many things in my life and made many excuses for the sins, but I never really forgave myself until recently. I had to look and say, "God, I admit that I sinned and there is no excuse." "Please, forgive me." It's hard for a human, such as myself, to understand why God forgives me, and I doubt that he uses the excuses that I offer him!
on Jul 26, 2004
opinions are ass holes and everybody has one, how dare you you desecrate CS Lewis' words in such a manner, you have no right to talk about forgiveness unless you have been there..I can tell from your tone you are just regurgitating someone else's thoughts. So please stick to what you know..you are one of those people who cheapens christianity


Wow, cry more!

on Jul 27, 2004
Andy, Kayles, I'm glad you found this article insightful.

Wuxiaomao -- I admit, your remark is confusing. Please entertain a rebuttal, since I'm deciding to leave your remark posted despite my disagreement with its uneccesary vulgarity.
First, notice I place this article under "philosophy," which I believe is the proper place for "opinions" as you classified my article. Moreover, the article is spiritual philosophy. I'm expecting spiritual discussion, not baseless insults.
Second, I notice you allege I desecrate C.S. Lewis' words and then later accuse me of regurgitating them. Either I'm desecrating them (implying they are sacred in some way) or I'm repeating them word for word. I'm unclear on this.
Third, you accuse me of cheapening Christianity because I'm in some way outside of my realm of experience and knowledge. As a devoted Christian (meaning someone who follows Christ and His teachings) I think I am certainly speaking on experience, ergo what I know. In turn, I question what you know about the subject because of your eagerness to pour hatred and judgment upon someone with whom you simply disagree.

Again, let me urge you all to actually read C.S. Lewis' essay entitled, "On Forgiveness," which may be found in the paperback called The Weight of Glory. I assure you I in no way "bastardized" what he was saying. I merely used it as a springboard to discuss my own spiritual walk and what I'm learning.

I enjoy hearing your stories of forgiveness -- what it has meant in your life -- as well.

By the way, Wux, I've forgiven offenses that make your ignorance and harshness dwindle to a grain of sand in the sea. Forgiving people for comments like yours is not really a problem because I've indeed been there. (PS -- out of curiosity, how did you determine my alleged "tone" in my essay?)