The things that make me laugh, weep, and live.
Ceasing to Be Human
Published on April 9, 2004 By Shulamite In Pure Technology
We've seen soldiers coming back from the war getting thier new limbs. The doctors tell them they'll work better than their old ones. And I've heard this is true; runners usually run faster, rock climber achieve new heights, if you will, and other athletes across the board perform better once they've adapted. We all accept the new prosthetics when we see them in use. It's not their actual arm... but it is. Now. And it works. And we're glad.

Already, amazing surgeries to fix our organs (eyes, heart, kidneys, et cetera) are commonplace. But are they going to the next level? Did you hear about the new internal organs they're making out of mechanical devices? They're experimenting with a mechanical heart for one. I think they're working on a liver and perhaps kidneys as well. Wow.

I saw a documentary with a man in Britain who had wired his entire house to acknowlege his presence wherever he was in the home. It would give him reminders and whatnot. It would know if a stranger was present. He did it all through computers and a chip he'd placed inside himself. His dream was to have a computer wired to his brain. That way he could easily store all that he wanted to store. Think about it. You'd never forget anything. He thinks he'll be able to do it in ten years working with the people he's got on the project.

So at that point, we've safely replaced our limbs. We've replaced our internal organs. We've even replaced our brains.

At what point do we cease being human?

Everything about us has the capacity to be mechanized. If our brains can be mechanized and computerized, our sight can be too. I've heard that militaries are experimenting with x-ray and night vision technology implants. That means your eyes automatically do it. They could focus great distances because you want them too. I learned our brains work on a system of electric impulses... how is that different than a computer, except maybe a little more complex and chemically based?

If all of this came true, if a person has internal mechanical organs, external mechanical limbs, and a brain that is wired to a computer for memory, vision, et cetera, are they still human?

What, for you, defines human? Would you discriminate against these people if you were "natural?" Would you feel superior if you were cyborgish?

Comments
on Apr 10, 2004

Hmm. I'm not sure I know of  a case yet where prosthetics work better than the real thing.

But point taken. I'd say it's our brains that make us human but of course, even then at some point it might be cyberneticlaly enhanced.

on Apr 13, 2004
Im sorry, but I disagree. I've never heard of limbs being replaced with cyb-parts that work better. And brains cannot be replaced at the moment. Scientists haven't even created an eye, yet you pronounce full compatibility with this imagenary technology. Please get your ideas in order with correct information before trying to make a point.
on Apr 13, 2004
Wow, such hostility from an anonymous user, Mykel. Are you feeling well?

Actually I read an article many many moons ago about a similar topic in the Christian Science Monitor. I also watched a much more complete documentary than what I could ever reproduce acurately (from memory) with my mere human brain that covered exactly what I said with much more evidence on the Discovery Channel.

See Mykel, to "get my ideas in order with correct information" I guess I need to go by what you've heard of as my standard. Is that what you're saying? Also, you tagged "at the moment" onto your brain argument as if that changes the "what if" nature of my inquiry. Also you condemn me to "pronouncing full compatibility with this imagenary technology" [sic] when hypotheticals allow a person to say "if and when." The fact you ignore is that health science technologists are doing things believed impossible only a decade ago. Do you by chance wear a buckle on your hat? I'm sorry, that may have been out of line. I apologize.

Mykel, did you know scientists have grown a complete ear in a petri dish?

And a rock climber introduced on the discovery special said he certainly does climb better now with his prothetic legs that are made especially for rock climbing. For one, they don't get cramps he said.

Brad didn't think prosthetics worked better either... but he still thought about the essential question regarding the essence of humanity. Sometimes I think the essence of humanity is the unique ability to complain, whine, offend, and be rude.